Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
i dont know if this was easy or hard XD
the one who can solve this must be very very good

i also that this kind of braintwisting is not much popular lol

its a crime mystery game
to those who love to solve riddles, mystery, brain teaser

difficulty level : medium

thanks to jester who help me in doing the flash :)
logic credit to @: WoW

Detective Shiki
:thumb201389654:

you can write the answer in comment section ^^

:police:
before you scroll down, the answer might be in the comment section

So far from all the comments only 5 have got it correctly XD
Add a Comment:
 
:iconazrayah:
Azrayah Featured By Owner Mar 7, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
It's Jack because he said he saw the killer's silhouette last night, but according to Shiki it was storming that night. Jack even says that the night was dark, so how could he have seen the silhouette?

There also isn't evidence of a struggle at the crime scene, and so the killer must have talked to the victim and the victim must have felt comfortable with the killer. Jack's already confessed that he's the victim's teammate, and being teammates is a matter of trust. Therefore, if Jack were to come up to him and talk to him about, oh, I don't know, joining a "better team" or something, then they'd be comfortable talking. At least, comfortable enough for Jack to stab him without a fight.

So, I say Jack is the killer, and my evidence/speculation is above. I hope I'm right but I have this feeling that my evidence might be off.
Reply
:iconmabelpoerava:
MabelPoerava Featured By Owner Jul 22, 2014
Ah!!!! I'm new to this game and I hardly play games like this, so I may get the answer wrong. Even so, that's fine. Here's my answer. (ENGLISH IS NOT MY MOTHER LANGUAGE, I MAY NOT BE CLEAR)

1. In the first slide, Shiki said that there was a storm last night. 

Meaning : The storm took place at night, but not morning or daytime. (I'll explain why that is necessary later on).

2. Basing on what I saw in the room or office and who's introduced, the killer has to be someone introduced to us. So it's either Jack, who may or may not murder him or the Victim, who may or may not committed suicide. On the Victim, it is clearly shown that there are three wound marks around his heart and no other object that has blood, except the pen. Seeing there's a soccer ball near the desk or appears to be laying on it, then there's the paper in front the victim and it has the word contract. The window is also open with the sun light hitting through it, and Jack is still wearing his uniform for soccer for some reason.

Meaning : Let's say the murderer is not Jack, or someone we haven't seen. So here's what I think happened. It is daytime that the murder happened, not the night when the storm is happening, because that will not explain why the window was open for the rain to come through. Seeing the contract, I think that the victim is planning to leave the team. If not, then the victim must be a new come. But that is not possible, because Jack said that they are in training this week. Meaning that they have train for some soccer battle, so there is no reason for the victim to sign a contract for being a new member of Jack's team. I'm thinking that the victim is signing a contract to move to another team, otherwise they don't want to be on any soccer team. If the victim didn't want to be on any soccer team and just quit, he could have just told the captain that he quits. So that concludes that he is signing a contract to move to another team. I think the murderer is Jack, because if it was the captain then... The Captain would have already done so before the victim could sign, since it requires the captains permission to let a teammate go on another team by contract.  So the team captain cannot be the murderer.

3. From what Jack told us, the victim is not the captain, but only a teammate as quoted. He saw the killer out the window, and he waited in here till morning to call the police. He also never touched anything in here.

Meaning : I can't tell if the window can be closed or not, since it lacks information on the drawing. It's suspicious.... Since he said he saw the killer, but I'm thinking what if the storm put out the power? Then again, no light bulb is drawn on the drawing. If the victim truly did die by the pen stab three times in his heart, then there is no reason for Jack to wait till morning. If the murderer had a gun or some weapon that can attack in long distance and murder the victim with it, then Jack would have a reason to hide. If it was the pen that can only kill by close range, then Jack could just run out or call the police when the murderer is gone. It's not like a pen can kill you when it's being thrown to you blindly in the storm, and who can see in a storm? The chance of getting hurt from a pen being thrown to you in a storm is 1 in a thousand. So there is no reason to stay in the room, I mean, a murder happened. The first thing you want is to get the police on this case right away. Besides, doesn't he have a phone ? Isn't there a phone in the office? It's a lie that he never touched anything in here, since there all these evidence pointed towards him.

Final Conclusion :  Here is what I think happened. During yesterday's daytime, the victim is in the office signing a contract to move to another team being given the permission from the captain.  Since everybody on the team has train this week, from what the murderer has told us. If that's true, then everybody must be out on the field. Since the victim who is moving to another team has no need for training, but just to complete the contract to move to another team. Since the murderer found out about what the victim is doing, he felt betrayed. (I'm sorry, I'm bad at motives. So I had to look in the comments for possible motives) That might be the motive, but that's all I can get my mind on. In the office, that's where the victim is in completing the contract. I don't think the victim is knock out, because what if they broke the window glass? The slides didn't say they were a professional team or such, there's no evidence. So I cannot take a chance on guessing that he was knock out by a soccer ball. Instead, I think that the murderer and the victim has a fight on the outside or maybe not. I think that the victim was stab outside. I mean wouldn't the blood get on you if you just stabbed someone's heart like that? Blood could have sure got spill on the ground, but if so. How did the murderer stab the victim without getting blood on himself? I think the murderer stab the victim from the behind. Since the opening of the would is in the front, blood would surely spill from the front. But if you stab the victim in his heart from behind, you would only get blood on your arm and skin only. Look at murderer's and the victim's uniform, they're short sleeves. So blood can only get on the the murderer's arm, but not clothes. When the night came, there was a storm. Since the storm bought rain, then the murderer could wash off the blood by the rain. The murder must have stayed over night to clean up and tampered with the evidence, because what kind of culprit would not do that when he has the time to do that and get away with crime? (Maybe the screw up ones?) When Shiki and Miji came, the blood on the victim's clothes had dry up and the window is wide open. But then, the murderer told us that he had not touched anything. If so, then the wide open window must have let rain came in. Even if all the rain had dried up before Shiki and Miji came, then remember this. The paper would be wrinkled if it came in contact with many rain droplets, but the drawing shows the contract paper is not wrinkle, but straight. If the window was open and the rain came in, then the blood on the victim's clothes would look blurry or faint. So the murderer has lied about on not touching anything before Shiki and Miji came. From my thinking and evidence, what the murderer truly said contradicts.
Am I right? The murderer is Jack and I have all the proofs explained. If there are any part you don't understand, please point it out.
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Mar 2, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
almost but its wrong :(
thank you for answering :)
Reply
:iconkitokitcaso:
kitokitcaso Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2014  Student Artist
Isn't it obvious or maybe not? Iam thinking his team mate is the killer and i have proof!
Proof 1.
If It is true he saw the killer escaping from the window why didn't it left footprints outside? unless the killer was still inside>
Proof 2.
How did the killer get inside? Or The victim did invited the murderer.
Proof 3.
If the killer had a pen in his hands he should be killed near the front door. so in that case when the killer was in the house he took the pen from the victim's office and stabbed him
Proof 4.
If the killer was leaving why didn't he take the murder weapon because if not the police will search for fingerprints!

So the only one can do that was you! JACK!
<Oh! and you were the only one with the victim last night and if you really did see the suspect why won't you tell the police what he looks like or stop the suspect from killing the victim?>
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Mar 2, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
almost but its wrong :(
thank you for answering :)
Reply
:iconkitokitcaso:
kitokitcaso Featured By Owner Mar 25, 2015  Student Artist
But why?
   Wait, but jack is still the culprit right?
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Jun 9, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
yes
Reply
:iconiammarrika:
IamMarRika Featured By Owner Apr 29, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Jack is the killer, but i dunno the answer... Hmm... Let me think of it again... Please Correct mee!!!

The murder was done in a small place downtown...

In the crime scene, the victim, is obviously stabbed by a pen, and the pen has some blood stains... 

But why would the murderer put those things so obvious?

Jack said that he never touched anything after he saw the victim...

He said that they have a training (obviously soccer) that week and he said LAST NIGHT, he saw the murderers' silhouette rushing in the window...

And again, why would the killer be so obvious if Jack is Right?

And why would Jack be scared of the killer to kill him? He said first right that he saw the murderers' silhouette rushing in the window... Which means the murderer has escaped...

I don't know whats the answer!! But I just found that unhelpful clues. I know its unhelpful!! The-dance   [EXO] Chanyeol Emoticon 

But I lyk itt!! Pony Approved!! :GIF: Clapping Dubby 
Reply
:iconiammarrika:
IamMarRika Featured By Owner Apr 29, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
It's still loading, and while I read the comments, I suppose, Jack's not the killer?
Reply
:iconwashishibo:
WashiShibo Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2014
it was jack he said the killer went out the window last night but the carpet is dry and when you consider that the weather was bad last night that means it clearly was not opened until morning
Reply
:iconwhitekitsune1:
whitekitsune1 Featured By Owner May 20, 2013
First of all, why would he be dressed up in his soccer field outfit inside of his office that early in the morning? Even if it had been done at night, there would be no reason to be dressed up to go play soccer during a storm at night. I believe the victim was called over by his colleague Jack, possibly that morning since it would be a clear day, great for going out and practicing some kicks. It wouldn't be uncommon for them to play in wet grass or even mud for that matter, even more so if the sun had dried up most of the water that fell last night.

From what I can see from the room, there is what looks to be a contract of sorts and a book next to that. There are also some trophies in the back. I believe the contract was placed there after the murder to try and set someone else up to look like the murderer as to throw off the suspicion from their self. Although I can't see the word on it too well, I believe the book next to the contract might have been a book related to the two team mates and was the lure that called him to the original crime scene, where the murderer was already waiting for him with the weapon in hand, which was later placed next to the contract on the desk to further help their case.

This being the case, the victim will have no doubt have not seen the act coming and was taken by suprise from behind and was stabbed three times viciously in the chest from behind. He probably held him there in his arm for a few moments as he bled, causing the blood trail to flow down his shirt, and then let him go, making the blood flow down his side causing the abnormal flow of blood down the front of his shirt later after it dried. The fact that the room is free from blood splatter and still rather tidy will be my evidence to help prove this theory. Because he attacked him from behind, he would not have gotten any blood on his own clothes if he had just held him there as he passed away, if he hadn't died from the first stab. If he was still alive after the three initial stabs, he might have been too shocked from his friend's actions that he did not fight back. Cleaning blood off of his hands and arms would be simple enough, even more so if he had worn gloves or something of the like.

The story of the man in the window at night was more than likely made up, whether the murder had occurred at night or early that morning. If it had happened at night, when he had opened the window, rain and wind would most likely enter the room and cause some distortion and damage, leaving behind evidence that this indeed was the case. But there is no sign of that happening. All we have is Jack's word of this, which as this point is flimsy at best. He said he waited until morning because he was afraid the man was still waiting for him out in the dark, which again is a flimsy story. He could have still called the police while he was there despite his cowardice. Even had he not waited, the suspicious person in his story might have seen him and thought it best to silence anyone who saw him to begin with and would have come back either way.

The soccer ball and both of their uniforms are very clean, being an outdoor sport, which leads me to believe this all occurred in the morning. Jack would be the number one suspect on my list as he has made claims that can be proven false and seems to show no remorse over his fallen team mate. Jack must have placed him in that chair after he killed him and the blood dried up, which explains why there are no blood stains anywhere in the room.

I hope I at least got most of it right. I'm not Conan, but I try to at least see the small details like he says you should do when trying to solve a case. ^_^ Even if it seems insignificant at first, it could be the one piece of evidence that cracks the case wide open!
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner May 21, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
hi, first of all, thank you for writing these all, but i didnt saw any mention of evidence , hehe, so you didnt get the right answer :)
Reply
:iconwhitekitsune1:
whitekitsune1 Featured By Owner May 21, 2013
Yeah, I did forget some details, but I did use evidence to explain my findings. The pen was obviously the weapon of choice as it's covered in blood sitting on the table. The window had to have been opened that morning. (just adding those since I forgot to mention them before.) I also forgot to mention the witness's comment about him seeing the murderer's silhouette going out the window. That would have to mean he was behind him in the same house when it happened. It wouldn't have been that dark in the room for him to of only seen a silhouette if the victim had been in there signing a contract. And even if someone else was the killer, I'm sure they wouldn't have neatly set the weapon back down on the desk neatly beside the paper if they were in a hurry, so it had to have been someone who was inside the house the whole time.

The only one who had the time to make sure everything was neatly placed and set up to look like an intruder had entered could only be Jack, who had been there the whole night waiting inside the house. Had he of called the Police that night his trick would have been figured out on the spot by the police, so he waited until morning to open the window to back up his story. He made too many mistakes when coming up with his story.
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner May 21, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
any one can wait in the house before the crime , so its no telling that jack did it , there is no evidence that youve mentioned that jack is the one who did it :)
Reply
:iconwhitekitsune1:
whitekitsune1 Featured By Owner May 22, 2013
Isn't that his soccer ball at the scene?
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner May 23, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
yes, its either jack or victims belonging, we dont know right? :)
Reply
Hidden by Owner
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner May 23, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
hehe, all the evidence where right in front of you, im pretty sure its all in that shortclip :)
Reply
(1 Reply)
:iconbreezyflake:
breezyflake Featured By Owner Mar 7, 2013
The window was open, wasn't it? Isn't that kind of odd? It was a storm last night, so the victim should have closed the window. That means the killer went through the front door, THEN opened the window to get out.

And the only person who could have went in through the front door without any hassle should've been Jack.

Plus, if the killer went out through the front door easily, he should have went out using the front door.

*my deduction's wrong, and I know it. lemme try again haha*
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Mar 8, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
^_^
Reply
:iconbreezyflake:
breezyflake Featured By Owner Mar 8, 2013
Also, how do you upload a flash? I'm trying to upload a .fla file and put it in the Flash - Games category but it says the category is wrong. I even changed it to .swf but still nothing :(
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Mar 8, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
that is the same process i did ^^
Reply
:iconmintytheicechao23:
mintytheicechao23 Featured By Owner Jan 23, 2013
it could be jack because he was the only one in the place at the time as well as the place being to tidy so the victim didn't struggle the victim could of screamed at the time of being murdered but that is not actually told. since jack saw the killer escape from the window so that means he was not asleep so the other question is what was he doing in the night. if he had gone to sleep that wouldn't stop the killer jumping through the window and killing him too. yes the murder weapon was the pen but there was also a football in the room so it could of been a accidental suicide by tripping on the ball and stabbing him but that does not explain the other two stabs. and jack says that he didn't move anything that would be a lie as well as the fact of him seeing the silhouette rush out the window. how could jack sleep if he knew there was someone outside waiting for him he wouldnt be able to he would be to scared and immediately close the window and lock it but since the window was still open he didnt hesitate at night if the killer came back.

im not good at detective work but i will still give it ago ^^
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Jan 28, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
you didnt show evidence, you just only speculate what happened on the crime scene..
Reply
:iconmintytheicechao23:
mintytheicechao23 Featured By Owner Jan 29, 2013
i know i said i was bad at it :iconsweatplz:
Reply
:iconmintytheicechao23:
mintytheicechao23 Featured By Owner Jan 23, 2013
so the killer was jack
Reply
:iconyefta03:
yefta03 Featured By Owner Jan 10, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
i know,its suicide
Reply
:iconlillyabbi:
lillyabbi Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2013  Student General Artist
It is Jack and I have enough proof by just one sentence!

Jack: I had to wait until morning to call the police because i was afraid the killer was in the dark waiting for me.

If what he said was true about the killer rushing out the window, he shouldn't be scared because the killers wouldn't just stand there tapping his foot whistling waiting for the cops. He would have already been down the street. So he made an excuse on why he didn't call the cops sooner so he could clean up his dirty mess >:D
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
im sorry , its wrong :)
Reply
:iconxdsuki:
XDsuki Featured By Owner Dec 15, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
I happen to stumble upon this game and I like it so here I go.
I think Jack is the murder.
The pen is the weapon causing 3 stabs on the victim.
The reason for murdering the victim was probably because he was jealous of him being a better soccer player than him. Since I see lots of tropheys in his room.
So, about that window...
I think the window was first closed during the day of the murder because the floor would have been wet due to the rain if the window was open all night during the storm.
Jake was already in the house on the day of the murder to do something with the victim. Then murder him with a pen.
Jake left the house and decide to go back to the scene to open the window to put the police off track. Assuming that the murder did jump off the window.
Jake said he saw the murder ride out the window, which indicated he was there at the scene and could have just used the victim's home phone to called police.
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
i apologize, its wrong :(
Reply
:iconxdsuki:
XDsuki Featured By Owner Dec 18, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
aw ok. I shall try again!
Reply
:iconmajorlucifer:
MajorLucifer Featured By Owner Dec 11, 2012  Student Traditional Artist
It's Jack .

He killed his friend and quickly go out of the window . But , he didn't call the police because the police would suspect him because his clothes were wet . It's from the storm last night and police would find it strange if they found jack in outside when there's a storm .

That's my deduction .
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Dec 12, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
wrong
Reply
:iconmajorlucifer:
MajorLucifer Featured By Owner Dec 12, 2012  Student Traditional Artist
ah....Im a bitch
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Dec 12, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
no
Reply
:iconmajorlucifer:
MajorLucifer Featured By Owner Dec 12, 2012  Student Traditional Artist
I can't even solve a case .
Reply
:icontorrle23:
Torrle23 Featured By Owner Oct 22, 2012
Jack,positive
Reply
:iconwildduo:
Wildduo Featured By Owner Oct 8, 2012
I solved this one already, right? I think I did, but it's darn near impossible to check.
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Oct 8, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
you havent yet ^^
Reply
:iconwildduo:
Wildduo Featured By Owner Oct 9, 2012
Goody! Then my deduction is as follows: (it's numbered so that you don't have to plow through a wall of text)

1.Jack is the murderer, that's a given.

2.I suspect the victim (From here on I'm just going to call him "Victim") called him over and tried to get him to sign on to another team.
3.Jack, incredulous that Victim would ask him to betray his team, picked up the pen and stabbed Victim with it.

3a. The rain might have had something to do with the general atmosphere, but that's just theory.

3b. Jack was so angry, he stabbed him three times without noticing the guy was already dead.

4. Coming back to his senses, Jack probably ran back to his own room.

5. The next morning, after the sun came out, he called the police and, realizing that he would be the only suspect, opened the window with the intention of saying that he saw the murderer leaving.

6. The evidence is that the room is completely dry, despite Jack's testimony stating that a. the murderer left through it during the storm, and b. that Jack had not touched anything since he discovered the body.

6a. To clarify, if Jack is telling the truth, then the papers or the carpet (which should take the longest to dry out) should be wet.

6b. This doesn't have much to do with the deduction, but even if the pen was cleaned, a luminol test can determine that the fountain pen was the murder weapon.

7. Jack will probably be prosecuted for second-degree murder. :iconobjectionplz:
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Oct 9, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
im sorry, almost got it but not the answer :)
Reply
:iconwildduo:
Wildduo Featured By Owner Oct 11, 2012
But closer than most other people, right? Okay, let me amend it. Everything's the same except as the last comment, except I'll add this:

6c. There was no light outside; for a silhouette to be seen, the figure must be in front of a light.

Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Oct 12, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
still wrong :(
Reply
:iconwildduo:
Wildduo Featured By Owner Oct 12, 2012
Boo. I'm sure I have the answer somewhere...
Reply
:iconnightdreamersshadow:
NightDreamersShadow Featured By Owner Sep 23, 2012  Hobbyist Artist
Page/click one said that it was stormy wreathless night.
Page/click five you see the murder scene (look at the floor under the open window)
Page/click six Jack said didn't touch anything in the room.
Page/click nine Jack says "Last night..out the window"
It's Jack because the floor wasn't wet after the storm last night.
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Sep 23, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
im sorry, youre wrong :)
Reply
:iconnightdreamersshadow:
NightDreamersShadow Featured By Owner Sep 24, 2012  Hobbyist Artist
Ok my sister says this “I say Jack, because first thing Jack says “I haven’t touch anything since I saw him…” implying that he came in that morning and saw his “friend” shot. But he then says that he “saw” the silhouette of the killer rushing out the window, implying that he was there when his ”friend” was shot.
So both cases can’t be true.”
Reply
:icontcwoua:
tcwoua Featured By Owner Sep 24, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
im sorry, its still wrong :), he didnt touch anything could mean that he was there all the time and tell the police that he didnt touch anything whole the time :)
Reply
:iconwilliamstockholm795:
WilliamStockholm795 Featured By Owner Aug 19, 2012
It was Jack who did it.
If you look closely at the victim's desk, there is a bloody object that is perfectly placed after the victim is stabbed three times in the chest. Take note that the killer went out of the window. If the murderer went out of the window and Jack was in the room witnessing the murder, why would the suspect bother to kill him in the first place.
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×




Details

Submitted on
September 3, 2010
Image Size
2.0 MB
Resolution
800×500
Link
Thumb
Embed

Stats

Views
16,394
Favourites
135 (who?)
Comments
1,385
Downloads
133
×